I Was Missing the Queen

Author: Larry Cohen
Date of publish: 05/27/2014
Level: All Levels

I often get phone calls from David Berkowitz. Out on the tournament trail, usually playing with regular partner Alan Sontag, I get to hear tales of this HOF-duo. Recently, David called me from a knockout match in a Denver regional. White against Red, "Sonty" was dealt: ?K9865
?4
?97
?AKQ107

David dealt and opened 1? (Precision--strong, forcing, artificial).  RHO overcalled 2? which showed clubs and either major.

 

Instead of hoping to collect a juicy vulnerable penalty, Sonty chose to just bid 2? (natural, 5+ spades and GF).

 

LHO bid 3? and David bid 4?.  This meant that David had a big hand (worth approximately 16+) and a good diamond suit (at least 5 -- but you'd think at least 6 to introduce the suit at this level). RHO bid 4?.  So, it had gone:

 

 

WestDavidEastSONTY
   1?*  2?& 2?
 3? 4? 4?  ??  

 

* Precison   & ?+Major

 

Expecting partner to have good diamonds, Sonty control-bid 5?. David now jumped to 7?!   This might be okay. He likely has the ?A, ?A and solid diamonds -- so all should be well.

 

But, the opening lead is the ?A.  This was my conversation as David continued to tell me the story:

 

Larry: "I guarantee you ruffed it.  I know it is strange they have 12 hearts -- but I know your bidding and there is no way you would have jumped to 7 with a first-round heart loser."

 

David: "You know me well. I did ruff."

 

Larry: "No doubt you had the ?A, -- so what about the diamonds?"

 

David: "I was missing the queen."

 

Larry: "So, you had 7? Did you play for the drop?"

 

David: "Not 7."

 

I knew if he had 6, that the percentages favor a 1st-round finesse (4-1 with Qxxx is much more likely than playing for the singleton queen offside by laying down a high one first).

 

Larry: "Only 6?"

 

David: "I said it the first time. I was missing the queen."

 

I pondered this a little longer and then finally figured out that he had 10 diamonds!!  All that was missing was the queen. He meant it literally.

 

His hand: ?A7
?--
?AKJ10865432
?4
.

 

Next time someone tells you they are missing the queen, maybe you'll think of this one. Incidentally, I recall having a 10-card suit only twice in my life. The odds are that you will get a 10-card suit about once every 59,000 deals.  So, if you play 3 sessions a week (say 72 deals) and every week -- that is 3,744 deals a year.  That would mean a 10-card suit every 16 years or so.